There is much joy in Brunswick these days as $35 million in taxpayer money has been made available to upgrade the train tracks between Portland and Maine Street Station. Work has already begun.
If I understand things correctly, the plan is to have an Amtrak train run between Portland and Brunswick twice a day, with a stop in Freeport.
Before that can happen, the $35 million will be sunk in the upgrade effort. Then trains will have to be found and put in condition to be dedicated to the run, and crews will have to be hired to operate and maintain them. The tracks will have to be maintained, inspected regularly, and plowed when necessary. And presumably the crossing gates and lights will have to be maintained and inspected on a much more rigorous schedule then they are now.
This is all with no real way of knowing how much ridership the train will generate.
It’s a foregone conclusion the train will not be self supporting for its recurring operation, let alone recoup the non-recurring investment. I’m not sure there’s an Amtrak run anywhere that can support itself.
I don’t know what kind of exposure the state has in this effort; there must be some, because bond issues have addressed rail transport, haven’t they? And our local Senator, Stan Gerzofsky, has promoted “investment,” I hear.
While it’s a bit late for such an experiment, wouldn’t it have made sense to “pilot” the idea of twice daily “public mass transit” runs between Portland and Brunswick? Wouldn’t this be a way to judge public demand and support for such services?
If this is such a good idea, a bus departing the Portland train station headed for Brunswick, with a stop in Freeport, and then returning, with two round trips per day, would provide a relatively low cost and immediate way to judge demand for this transit alternative.
No up front investment to speak of would be required; buses and drivers could be easily acquired; the transit times should be in the same ballpark as the train; and the fares could be far lower than the train will charge. Or at the worst, for sake of realism, the same.
This could be up and running in a matter of weeks, providing a viable option for the fall tourist season and the holiday shopping period. If this bus option couldn’t generate enough interest to make a go of it, what makes us think a train, likely at far greater expense and higher fares, will ‘fare’ better?
For that matter, why hasn’t some private concern established this exact route to up their profits? I suppose the question answers itself.
The “romance of the rails” is one thing, but to think that alone will generate and sustain a critical mass of ridership for a 25 mile commuter run is a real stretch of the imagination. Have you watched one of the Maine Eastern summer trains pass through town and counted heads in the windows?
But then that’s why we have government here to help us, I suppose. And taxpayers in servitude to finance the help.
PS: while it might seem too late to try, it could still provide early benefits to Brunswick and Freeport economies if the demand is really there. And if it isn’t, the losses could be cut before and if the train were to become an expensive failure and embarrassment.