Showing posts sorted by relevance for query insurance. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query insurance. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, October 29, 2011

No-bid naughtiness: the details so far….

You’ve probably already forgotten, and frankly, we wouldn’t blame you, that we introduced this subject here.  And then we teased you to be ready for a follow-up here.

We’re now ready to provide that follow-up.  Our only reason for the delay is that we were busy enjoying life, if you don’t mind us doing so.  We visited North Jersey, where we were born and raised, to visit our daughter and family, who relocated there in recent months.  And to join in a partial family reunion in the Lancaster, PA area, heart of Amish/Pennsylvania Dutch country.  It was an enjoyable and rewarding several days.

Back to business; we promised we’d update you with specific information once we had it, and here we come.  We also need to tell you that the activity level in this subject area is far higher than we had anticipated.  As so often happens, once you start looking into things, new insights and information start coming your way.

Before we report on what we’ve found, you might want to read this article: teacher's health insurance.  Serendipitously, we got the link from a friend; it’s ‘right in the wheelhouse’ of our discussion, and you should find it illuminating.

As to specific information, here’s what we have so far:

Brunswick School Department insurance figures, provided by their Finance Director, are as follows:

Total: $4,805,000, of which $4,430,000, or 92% goes to MEA coffers, and 3.4% goes to the MMA.  (MEA is the Maine Education Association – the state teacher’s union; MMA is the Maine Municipal Association – the state ‘union’ of municipal governments.)

Employee Medical $4,430,000; from MEA benefits trust; these are ‘public funds only.’  Employee contributions for medical insurance are $533,154 in addition to employer share  of $4,430,000.  In other words, total funds to the MEA for Brunswick school department employee health insurance are a shade under $5 million.

Employee Dental $150,732; from Securian.

Workers Compensation $136,934; from MMA.

Motor Vehicle  $7,595; Kyes Agency, Farmington.

Liability  $19,985; Kyes.

Property Casualty  $60,024; Kyes.

Let’s extrapolate those figures to statewide totals.

Brunswick has less than 2500 students, in a state that  has about 180,000 total.  If the per student payments to the MEA and MMA were equal state wide, the school departments would be spending a total of nearly $360 million on insurance with the MEA, and $9.8 million  with the MMA.  Here in Brunswick, we’re sending the MEA about $2,000 per student on employee medical alone.

Wow times twenty! 

On the municipal side, here are the figures:

MMEHT – Health Insurance - $1,646,576.79 of which $1,332,621.00 is paid by the Town of Brunswick, and the remainder paid by employees.  (This is the health insurance program run by the MMA.)

MMA Worker’s Compensation Pool - $183,032.83 all paid by the Town of Brunswick.

MMA Property & Casualty Risk Pool -  $156,654.30 all paid by Town of Brunswick.

(Everything else is down in the noise for or purposes here.)

Summing up, from what we know, our municipal government spends about $2 million on insurance annually with the MMA.  If Brunswick is typical, the MMA does about $140 million in total insurance business state-wide.

Based on figures we’ve seen in recent years, this insurance business yields about $8 million in excess revenue (“profit” in business terms) for the MMA.  If the MEA has the same ‘profit’ margin, their insurance business would turn a ‘revenue excess’ of more than $20 million.

In both cases, since neither is a public corporations with stockholders, these profits are available for use as the organizations see fit – most typically, in partisan political activism and lobbying efforts.

These figures set the stage for examining activity in the Maine legislature in recent months.  Two bills have been passed and signed into public law that address the conduct of MEA insurance operations.

The first began as LD 1326, “An Act To Allow School Administrative Units To Seek Less Expensive Health Insurance Alternatives.”  You can find the status summary for the bill here.  If you do, the most important thing to note is that the bill passed on a largely party line vote.

The law, as passed, is not a mandate of any sort; it simply requires that school districts be given access to claims experience information they need to pursue the option of competitive bids for health insurance; information that the MEA and their selected insurer have been able to legally withhold in the past.

The second bill, which began as LD 404, also became law, and is entitled “An Act To Assist School Administrative Units In Providing Health Insurance to Their Employees.”  In basic terms, this law requires that school department administrators seek competitive bids for health insurance for their employees at least once every 5 years, rather than being permanently locked in to the MEA statewide plan.  Pretty radical stuff, huh? 

According to reports we’ve received, the MEA devoted considerable effort to lobbying against these bills.  They were unsuccessful, as the new legislative majorities were supportive of competition as a fundamental method for delivering best value for taxpayer dollars.

This did not sit well with the teachers’ union, and the MEA is therefore pursuing further legal action to have the laws overturned.  You can read about it here.  This press release reads, in part, as follows:

Maine Education Association Challenges New State Health Care Laws

10/14/2011 03:23 PM ET

The MEA's Health Benefit Trust, which covers tens of thousands of Maine educators and their families, contend that the new laws will weaken its system.

The Maine Education Association's Health Benefit Trust is challenging two new Maine laws it says will weaken the system that covers tens of thousands of Maine teachers and their family members.

The Health Benefit Trust filed a suit in federal court Oct. 12 aimed at blocking the implementation of LD 1326, which requires the Trust's insurer, Anthem-BlueCross and Blue Shield, to release the claims history or "experience rating" for any school unit that requests the information.  (Oh the horror!)

In addition, the MEA's board of directors has authorized a legal challenge to LD 404, a new law which requires the Health Benefit Trust to use a competitive bidding process and to create a lower-cost insurance option by July 1 of 2012. 

The full statement is loaded with the equivocation and stereotypical rhetoric of politically protected special interest groups; we choose not to confront you with all of it, lest you suffer gastric unrest.  But you can go for the full Monte if you wish; just click on the link above.

Hence we come to this: what is our point in discussing all of this? 

Lacking anything more compelling, we suppose it’s to ask these questions:

1) Why would one party join forces with a special interest, very powerful union, to block ordinary taxpayers from being able to access the benefits of the competitive open market?

2) Why would the Maine Teachers’ Union be so willing to go to the mat, and invest big lobbying dollars, to protect their established monopoly in school department health insurance coverage?

The questions, we believe, answer themselves.  It’s to make sure the union can keep funding THEIR sons-a-bitches, in order for them to maintain privileged status over ordinary tax-paying citizens who are tired of more money in education buying less and less in the way of results.

When will you conclude we’ve had enough?  With all the news breaking lately on favored interests getting their way, how much longer do you think we can endure this flagrant abuse of common sense and the true public interest?

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

No-bid naughtiness, Municipal style

Remember during the Bush administration (“do you miss me yet?”) how we were constantly hammered with news reports of no-bid contracts being given to Haliburton, the company once headed by Dick Cheney, VP to President Bush?  It goes without saying that government procurement activities, given the absurdly huge sums involved, and the political meddling always present, provide more than enough opportunity for mischief, or far worse.  More about that in upcoming posts.

Funny, then, how no one makes an issue of no-bid contracting by local government, in this case, the Town of Brunswick, and the Brunswick School Department.  Contracting that has clearly political implications.  There’s enough here of interest that you’d think any newspaper worth its salt would have an investigative reporter digging into the subject.  Which explains why The Ostrich hasn’t so much as mentioned the subject.

Let’s take things one at a time.  You may have heard of the Maine Municipal Association, a non-profit enterprise that is, in effect, a wholly owned subsidiary of all but one or two municipal governments in Maine. The MMA is a highly visible presence in Augusta, lobbying for the interests of said governments, most often in opposition to the interests of individual taxpayers who fund them.  They dig their heels in whenever the slightest challenge to government status quo arises.  Think TABOR and other recent initiatives.

We know a little about MMA operations.  Their operating revenue derives from two sources.  The first is dues charged to member municipalities,  which amounts to roughly $1 million per year.  The second is insurance operations, in which they provide various forms of coverage to member municipalities.  Profit from this activity is in the range of $8 million a year.

You can trust us on this; our numbers are in the right range.

The $8 million in profits from insurance operations has largely been used to fund a variety of partisan political activities.  Especially campaigns to defeat or approve citizen initiatives on behalf of their municipal government members.

One might reasonably ask, therefore, whether towns are getting the best possible deals on their insurance coverage.  Especially if they are not sending it out for bids on an annual basis, commensurate with the annual budget cycle.

We’re not sure how much Brunswick pays to the MMA for insurance products, but we will follow up and report to you when we get the answer.

Now let’s move on to the other face of this phenomenon.  The Maine Education Association is the statewide teachers’ union, and they are immensely powerful in matters that drive school department budgets.  Surprise, surprise; they also operate an insurance business in addition to basic member representation services.

We are not nearly as familiar with MEA operations as we are with those of the MMA, so we won’t make any estimates of their scope.  We note, however, that the Brunswick School Department employs many more than town government, and their budget is more than 60% of overall town spending.

We presume, then, that the School Department spends more on insurance products with the MEA than the municipal side does with the MMA.  Again, you have our word that we will do our best to run these figures to ground.

The teachers’ unions, at both the state and national level, are far more engaged in partisan political advocacy than is the MMA.  We conclude that their insurance operations are more lucrative.  And we can easily imagine that purchasing insurance through the union is a non-negotiable aspect of teachers’ contract discussions.

Where are we going with this?  We’re going to a conclusion that the financial interests of taxpayers are ill-served by the insurance purchase processes of both municipal government and the school department.  And that it’s time that both put the purchase of all insurance out to bid on the open market as a matter of course.

Each of you reading this should contact your town councilor and school board member to demand that they see that this happens.  If they won’t, you have evidence that being a good steward of taxpayer resources is not a priority for them.

Old and lazy as we are, you have our personal commitment to look into a statewide effort to stimulate rigorous competition, on an annual basis, for this insurance coverage.  If the MMA and MEA win that competition, fine.  They will have structured their pricing to win.  If not, they will have been displaced by private sector providers who offer a more competitive product.

Either way, taxpayers win.  Who can argue with the motivation and the outcome?

Other than those who believe government monopolies are a good thing.   And that local insurance agencies shouldn’t have a chance to save us money.

Friday, August 14, 2009

"Guaranteed Issue" and the consequences

Amongst the most frequent reasons we're given that the government simply must reform (take over, really) our "health care" system are that the premiums are going through the roof and becoming more and more out of reach for 'working people,' and that we have way too many people who are uninsured.

Maine is a guaranteed issue state on health care insurance. That means you can wait until you are sick and need insurance before you purchase it, and you can't be denied. That all sounds very caring and compassionate.

So let's try that fine idea in some other areas. Suppose we were guaranteed issue on auto insurance as well, and you could get away without it until you have an accident. Then, as you ride in the tow truck taking your vehicle to the body shop, you call an insurance agent on your cell phone to purchase insurance, and he can't turn you down, even for "pre-existing" conditions.

Do you think that would increase the number of folks who find it's in their best interests to stay out of the auto insurance market until they are in need of it? What would that do to the number of "uninsured?" And for the rest of us silly gooses who follow the old custom of buying insurance as a matter of course, do you think our premiums would suddenly start escalating at outrageous rates? How could they not, when an increasing number of drivers are not contributing to the insurance "pool," but are simply emptying it?

Suppose that same person could drop his insurance after his car is fixed and paid for by his mandatory issue insurance? How would that work out for the rest of us?

Now let's look at Homeowner's Insurance. Suppose the legislature enforced guaranteed issue on that as well. Then you could save all the money you are now spending on such coverage, and wait until your house burns down, if ever. If and when it does, simply call your local agent and get the guaranteed issue covering "pre-existing conditions" before you contact a builder to get your place repaired or replaced. And then you can drop the coverage again after your builder gets paid.

How do you suppose that would effect the number of "uninsured homes," and what would be the effect on the premiums for those saps who think your home should be covered all the time as a matter of peace of mind? And "fairness?"

Now go back and think about the complaints about health care that I began this discussion with...too many uninsured, and premiums way too high and getting higher.

Then ask yourself who caused the problems leading to these complaints. And more important, ask yourself WHY they did it. Until you can answer that question, you can't fully grasp what's going on now.

And you might think about Pogo while you're at it.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Rooks and Health Care Reform: Ignoring Cause and Effect



Let’s just stipulate up front that I find Doug Rooks to be a thoroughly annoying big government propagandist (or worse) who specializes in shallow and uncritical thinking. It only makes it worse that our local “watchdog of government” free press pays him for his efforts, and prints them with that innocent and kindly little photo to disarm readers.

Rooks wrote recently about “effective reform” of health care reform.

This time around, I won’t parse the details of his effort and respond. Mostly because Rooks’ regular intake of Kool-Aid has caused him to completely miss the larger issue.

Caring liberals like Rooks don’t recognize the relationship between causes and effects in public policy. Effects are where the emotional capital is; that’s why we often see ‘special guests’ at various political events who have a terribly sympathetic story about how they were affected by some perceived wrong.

At the same time, we never see politicians rolled out who were the cause of so many of our problems. Instead, we find politicians, and often the ones who caused some “problem,” touting how they have the solution for it, if only we’d give them more money.

Linking cause and effect is typically denounced as “fixing the blame” when we need to “fix the problem.” Well, if they don’t understand the cause of the effect, their attempts to fix it fall into the “do something, do anything” category of blunt instrument legislating, calculated mostly to generate much public praise.

In Maine, especially, the dominant challenges in health care coverage that cause hair to spontaneously combust have been caused almost entirely by government intervention and policy. And the worse the problems get, the more those who caused them insist that we must let them solve them. In doing so, they exhibit the first signs of a sort of collective dementia, where they can’t seem to remember leaving the oven on, but they insist that we buy them air conditioning to cool the kitchen down.

I’m going to explain by making a half dozen or so assertions about the underlying causes. I invite any and all to challenge these points.

1) The governing majority in Maine over the last 30 or more years has actively driven up the cost of health insurance by enacting regulations such as guaranteed issue, community rating, and a rich list of mandated coverage for all buyers, regardless of their needs and desires. The net results are that buying coverage in Maine can cost nearly twice what it does in New Hampshire, and that the private insurance market finds operating in Maine to be unattractive. Most have left, and the notion of free market forces and “competition” is virtually non-existent.

2) To make things even better, the ruling majority has made sure we can’t buy insurance available from companies in other states, like we do with our auto and homeowner’s insurance. Result: buyers trapped in a tightly restricted market with the highest possible prices.

3) Maine is the oldest state in the nation, increasing overall demands on the health care system. At the same time, average incomes are very low. Result: with the high prices described in the previous points, we end up with the perfect storm of high utilization, high insurance prices, and inadequate income to pay for it.

4) Maine’s overall economic policy, especially taxation and business friendliness, virtually guarantees that the median age will continue to increase, and that the younger entrepreneurial demographic needed to pay for public services will continue to leave and/or avoid the state. Bluntly speaking, the state is in a demographic winter leading to a death spiral, and “quality of place” is not enough to turn it around. Pundits like Rooks either can’t understand, or avoid the truth because they simply can’t accept it. They’re in the denial stage, and won’t move on to more productive discussions.

5) In other words, we find ourselves with a broken and unsustainable “system.” We have more demand for health care services, an increasingly unaffordable insurance product, and an income base that is hopelessly tilted towards poverty levels.

6) Consequently, more and more people exit the private market and enter the public programs. Maine’s Medicaid enrollment figures are the highest in the nation, and we continue to relax eligibility rules.

7) It’s clear that state government is virtually totally responsible for the increases in private insurance premiums because of excessive regulation and mandates, coupled with driving out competition and cost shifting to cover the gross underpayment public programs make to health care providers.

8) Government claims that private program premiums are skyrocketing and generating huge profits while shamelessly masking the clear unsustainability of public programs. If costs of public programs were stated in the form of annual premiums, the government programs would be increasing in cost more quickly than the private programs.

9) At least if real costs were addressed; but they are not. Government “reimburses” at most 60-80% of actual costs of public care. Result: “real costs” get shifted to the private insurance market, further exacerbating the cost of that product.

10) To add insult to injury, the state does not even pay the bills it incurs at those artificially low reimbursement levels. Maine currently owes $400 million plus to health care providers, and there is no reason to believe the state is committed to pay off that balance. Why? Because they can, and it’s virtually impossible to collect – they are the government, and no one will take them on.

Add all these factors together, and you have a “system” that is destroying itself. Inputs, feedback loops and controls are inadequate to the need. Simply changing how the bills are paid will not correct the fundamental weaknesses in the overall economic climate.

And we owe it all to government. And it's clear that further government involvement will only lead to more problems.

But I guess that’s OK for some. The more problems government causes, the more political careers that can be advanced by proposing to fix them. It should be fun to watch when the private sector providers are completely eliminated, and the only thing left to demonize and blame is government itself. There'll be no option left except a circular firing squad.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

The ‘Soft Indifference’ of Low Expectations

Some years ago, President Bush (43) spoke the phrase “the soft bigotry of low expectations.”  As I recall, he was referring to the public education system, and how it’s all too easy to lower our expectations for minorities and/or those in poorer areas.

I thought it was an insightful concept, and I still do, and now I see a broader meaning to the concept in our own circumstances.

As I think back to my days in school, I remember two primary motivations to do well (besides my insatiable thirst for knowledge…ha, ha!)  One was the fear of my parents reaction if I didn’t.  The second, which was even stronger, was the fear of being “left back” as we called it then.  Nobody wanted to stay behind when all your friends moved up, and find yourself a sore thumb in the grade you were repeating.  And in later years, nobody wanted to “flunk out.”

Nowadays, my sense is that such antiquated concerns and realities no longer have any relevance in out government run schools.  When’s the last time you heard of a student being “left back,” or flunking out?  There may be an instance here or there, but I’ve come to believe that ‘seat time’ promotions and ‘social’ promotions have become the preferred way of addressing lack of classroom performance.

The first time I heard the term ‘seat time promotion’ I was taken aback.  It was explained to me that if your attendance was acceptable, you would be promoted, regardless of performance in the coursework.

For years I’ve heard the radio ads seeking literacy volunteers to help adults learn to read (and hopefully, write), and wondered how we could have adults who made it through our school systems without learning to read.  I think the answer lies largely in the promotion policies described above; rather than tackle the problem, the system prefers to look the other way and just keep moving the kids up and eventually out, giving them diplomas that are increasingly meaningless.

I asked myself how we could allow such an irresponsible policy to become the norm; how could we so diminish expectations as to render them irrelevant to moving through the system.

Then it dawned on me; this is exactly the way we deal with our teachers, and if it’s good enough for the teachers, it sure should be good enough for the kids.

What do I mean?  Take a look at the teachers contracts here in town and elsewhere, and you’ll find that they are the very essence of ‘seat time’ or ‘social’ promotion through the salary increase system.  Every teacher can look at the contract and project exactly what they will make in coming years, without regard to merit or performance by any measure.  Do the time, earn the credits, get the salary shown.

The very worst teachers move through the salary steps and lanes just as quickly as the very best teachers do.  Occupy your ‘seat’ for a year, and move up a year on the scale.  In other words, as Woody Allen famously said, 80% of success is simply showing up.  And that’s especially true of our pampering and homogenizing of the teachers corps.

Under the circumstances, is it any wonder the ‘professionals’ in the field would be so willing to promote their students without expecting much from them to earn it?

By the way, if you’d like to get a sense of how the State Teachers Union (MEA) guides the local contract negotiation process, just read what follows.  Note, among other things, that should the School Department expect teachers to pay more of their insurance costs, they want their salary to increase to cover that, after other expected increases.

From where we sit, the soft indifference of low expectations is a tragic and near irreversible trend in our public education system, at least under current circumstances. 

And it doesn’t say much about honoring the notion that ‘the children are our future,’ does it.

==================================================

Maine Education Association
Statewide Bargaining Goals
2010-2011

Wages and Salaries:
1. All bargaining unit members should receive a real increase annually, i.e. a wage or salary increase at least equal to the annual increase in the cost-of-living, after accounting for any increased costs to the employee for maintenance of insurance benefits.
2. Negotiate salary and wage structures that eliminate “dead zones” (multi-year steps without a rate change) and reduce the number of years required to reach the maximum rate on each lane. (Suggested long term goal – no more than 10 steps by 2020.)
2.1 When the State mandates minimum salary or wage levels, associations should negotiate improved scales in which the salary or wage base amount equals or exceeds the mandated minimum amount without extending the length of time required to reach the maximum.

Health Insurance:
3. Maintain or increase the employer-paid share of employee and dependent health insurance premiums, without compromising the health coverage and benefits of the existing plan.
3.1 Associations should reject health insurance plans that reduce premium costs by shifting health care costs to consumers, such as high deductible health care plans, whether or not enticements such as health savings accounts or health reimbursement accounts are offered.
4. Negotiate the same health insurance benefits for all teachers and educational support professionals.

Hours and Working Conditions:
5. Eliminate or reject any provisions that result in two-tiered systems where some employees are limited to lower wages or salaries, benefits or working conditions.
6. Workload – All contracts should address workload.
6.1. Teachers’ unit contracts should deal with workload by language either regulating the amount of work to be performed or requiring additional compensation when the work exceeds specified standards. Aspects of workload that should be addressed in this manner include required duties or meetings outside the work day or work year; planning time; and performance of non-instructional duties.
6.2. Contracts for educational support professionals should deal with workload by specifying work schedules and the length of the work day, work week and work year; and requiring that employees be paid at their regular or overtime rate as appropriate for all hours that they actually work.
7. Eliminate or reject any provisions which result in the Association waiving or giving up its right to bargain about any mandatory subject of bargaining.
8. Negotiate grievance procedures that end in final and binding arbitration.
9. Negotiate just cause protection, to the extent that it is not legally prohibited, for any disciplinary action.
10. Negotiate reduction in force procedures based on objective criteria only, e.g. seniority, certification, authorization, licensure, etc., with no consideration to employee evaluations.
11. Negotiate current and accurate job descriptions that are maintained and reviewed annually and when changes in responsibilities take place.

Recommended by the MEA Statewide Bargaining Committee–March 6, 2010

Saturday, May 1, 2010

“This and That” – May 1, 2010

A brief collection of items worthy of your awareness:

Traditional Media Circulation Continues To Slide

According to “media-mutt” Al Diamon, Maine’s established print media are continuing to lose circulation.  While the Press Herald and some others have declined to submit their recent figures, those that have show a consistent loss of readership (paid, at least.)

Brunswick’s revered Ostrich continued to demonstrate the wisdom of editorial policies that cater to less than half of their potential readership.

The Times Record in Brunswick was no exception to the trend. It went from a daily circulation of 8,673 a year ago to 8,091 now, a loss of 6.7 percent. The weekend edition dipped from 10,366 in 2009 to 9,583 in 2010, down more than 7.5 percent.

For the rest of the story, look here.

Public Sector Getting Rich on the Backs of the Middle Class

Got your attention there, didn’t I.  Regular readers know we’ve reported on the excesses of “public sector” unions before.  You may want to grab your ankles, or at least your knees, before you read further on this report though.

A periodical that we subscribe to recently carried an article that included this citation:

In Contra Costa, California, the final salary of one fire chief, 51, was $221,000. He was given an annual, guaranteed pension of $284,000. Another chief, 50, whose final salary was $185,000, got a pension of $241,000. Credit the Contra Costa Times with uncovering this.

You can read the entire article here.  And check out a referenced source here.

Too bad you didn’t take that job as a California fireman when you had the chance.  And 250 million Americans are thinking the same thing.

Coastal Journal – Government “Rescues the Economy”

Is your back hurting from bending over to absorb the last little snippet of good news?  Poor you; you better get used to it.

The Coastal Journal, which as we’ve opined before is the vehicle by which Editor Gina Hamilton earns a living while spewing collectivist and liberal orthodoxy, carried her “analysis” of the Obama administration’s plan for “Rescuing the economy” here.

I’ll spare you the gory details, other than to report that her review of the plans includes intentions to create a lovely array of new government agencies to oversee and improve our lives. The items below combine the “best ideas” of the house and senate versions of the bill.

Consumer Financial Protection Agency: Creates an independent agency with scope over financial products such as deposit accounts and loans.

Systemic Risk: Creates a new agency, called the Financial Services Oversight Council, which identifies threats to the stability of financial markets.

Investor Protection: Strengthens the SEC, and orders a study of the securities industry that will identify needed reforms.

Insurance: Creates a federal Insurance Office that will monitor all aspects of the insurance industry, including identifying gaps in regulation. (Or, if you prefer: Creates an Office of National Insurance in the Treasury Department to monitor insurance industry issues, coordinate international issues, and provide information and recommendations.)

Credit Rating Agencies: Creates the Office of Credit Ratings in the SEC.

Well!  I hope you feel better, because we certainly do.  How could we not when our aristocracy plans to create so many new agencies to look after our interests?  In all likelihood, the new government jobs will knock a tenth of a percent or two off the unemployment rate.  How could this not be good for us?

And now you know the Other Side of the story.

Technorati Tags: ,,

Saturday, October 15, 2011

No-bid naughtiness – a heads up

Earlier this week, we posted on the insurance operations of the Maine Education Association (the state teachers’ union) and the Maine Municipal Association, and what we believe to be a wide-spread no-bid relationship between these ‘organizations’ and the school departments and municipalities that procure their insurance from them.

We suggested that there may be opportunities for reaping significant savings by competing the coverage in the open insurance market.  While this thought has been in the back of our mind for some time, it was only by chance that we decided to address it now.  We promised we would gather some more data and report back, and if things looked promising, to pursue further action in the matter.

Well, wouldn’t you just know it; there has been some significant legislative interest in the subject this year, and it illuminates the political interests and sensitivities of the insurance operations.  Which is to say that who holds the majorities makes a big difference.

Once we conclude our look into things, we expect to post some eye-opening results.  Unless we get sidetracked, that should be within the next two weeks.

So stand by for some ‘education’ from your local non-profit wannabe reporter.

Technorati Tags: ,,

Sunday, October 25, 2009

On Health Care "costs"

About 23 years ago, in another place, a land far, far away, a young, bright, and extremely competent medical specialist..a urologist...saved my life as I see it.

He rescued me from kidney cancer, and we began a lifelong 'relationship' in the medical sense.

I touch base with him from time to time to get his take on the state of the health care industry. Generally speaking, what I hear from him would not encourage you, as the overwhelming trend in the system is to devalue the role and contribution of the medical care provider.

Most recently, I asked him about the burden malpractice insurance places on the system. If you've been paying attention, you know that the issue of "tort reform", or in simpler words "medical liability reform," has been largely excluded from the ongoing national debate. The consensus is that this is so because lawyers who deal in such matters have great influence over the debate; in other words, they are a special interest of the first order.

On to more specifics. I asked my specialist friend how much malpractice insurance adds to his annual expenses. He replied that in California, because of regulatory reform, this insurance costs about $25,000 per year, or about $500 per week.

He adds that in other states, coverage can run 5 to 10 times that amount annually, or $500 to $1000 per day! Think about that.

How much does this add to the overall cost of "health care" in this country? You can't easily know, because the subject, as I mentioned, is being kept off "the radar screen."

Probably because it's so very clear what a drag on the system this is. If a Doctor pays $500 a day in insurance costs, and sees 25 patients a day, each patient carries a $20 per visit cost simply for insurance purposes. If more critical specialists, like OB/GYNs, pay $1000 per day, than each patient visit carries a $40 burden having nothing to do with pure health care, but only to cover the various loaders on the system.

And we wonder why our system costs so much. More importantly, we should wonder why our so called "public servants" refuse to address this liability issue.

I think I know; how about you?

Friday, March 1, 2013

Bowdoin ponders one-upping Yale, others

(Ed. Note: this post was revised on Saturday morning 2 March. The added material has been underlined for your convenience.)

<absurdem>  <parody>

We don’t suspect you saw this recent item in the news; you pay Side to stay abreast of such things and pass them along when they merit your notice.

http://yaledailynews.com/blog/2013/02/25/yale-health-considers-sex-change-surgery/

The opening paragraph reads as follows:

Though Stanford, the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard and Brown offer health insurance coverage for students to receive gender reassignment surgery, Yale is still reviewing its policies for the procedure.

Followed soon thereafter by these words:

Gabriel Murchison ’14, president of the Resource Alliance for Gender Equity, said the lack of coverage is a sign of how unwelcoming the campus environment is for prospective transgender, gender nonconforming and queer students.

“The [current] policy sends a message to trans and gender nonconforming students that our concerns are not a priority, not to mention its effect on students who need this care and rely on the Yale Health Plan for their health coverage,” Murchison said.

“Well!” we say, with a modicum of exasperated melodrama.  Think Jack Benny.  And here we thought we’d ‘seen it all,’ when V-Day Celebrations and Vagina Monologues productions became campus standards!  ‘Please come, Mumsy; it will be so liberating!’

We are curious, though, as to why we never hear of P-Day events and the like.  Probably the same reason there isn’t a major in Masculinism.  Anyone with the ‘stones’ (to be polite) to propose either would likely be subjected to immediate academic castration and intellectual emasculation, which could be seen as ‘gender reassignment,’ we suppose.

Ironically, colleges these days are engaged in ‘free market competition’ for the best students, even though they all preach disdain for the ‘unseen hand’ in such matters.  That’s just another dimension of the faux ‘intellectual consistency’ mentioned in our prior post.

Bowdoin, of course, would love nothing more than one-upping Yale, Harvard, Stanford, and the other stuffed shirts in this anything but friendly competition.  At the same time, Bowdoin would have an institutional case of the vapors if anyone were to suggest that it has ‘an unwelcoming campus environment’ for ‘non-conforming’ students, regardless of how fluid that term may be.

Gender reassignment?  This is so yesterday, and is not the bold new frontier of academic  progress.

So we expect soon to read reports that Bowdoin is adding the following special health insurance coverage for students, faculty, and administration:

Ethnicity reassignment: just as Bill Clinton was the ‘first black American President,’ students can declare that while they are visibly white, they feel black, and are entitled to have their ethnicity surgically reassigned.  Or for those once derisively labeled ‘Oreos,’ they can surgically be made white, all at no personal expense.

Dogmatic theology reassignment: some students have reportedly claimed that while others label them ‘greens,’ or environmentalists, they really feel like communists.  They will qualify for pigmentation transplants that change their dominant skin tone from green to red.

Ideology reassignment: admittedly, very few students fall into this benefit category.  It addresses those who wish to pursue a career in academia, but come from conservative origins.  The coverage trains them to forsake reality and everything they know to be true in order to ‘fit in.’

Personality change surgery: some students have noticed that a Type A personality in a Type B environment, or vice versa, can be problematic.  Though experimental in nature, the insurance plan provides appropriate mind altering medications to resolve any feelings of self-doubt.

Wealth revulsion therapy: campus dogma preaches the evils of capitalism and wealth accumulation, while deifying the collectivist mantras of the 99%.  Realizing that if they are to succeed in their post-graduate pursuits, and measurably enhance the College endowment and their own stature in the eyes of future students, those afflicted will undergo intensive tutelage by Gordon Gecko, Visiting Professor of Meritorious Greed.

Name-change procedures: this coverage falls under the non-invasive out-patient category of the group policy.  Hyphen-otomies and other procedures that reallocate cognomens from patriarchally dominant to matriarchally dominant sensibilities will be freely available, and can be repeated on an annual basis.  The Elsbeths, Dylans, Quinns, Pats, Chris’s, Alexs and other afflicted seekers will be free to reverse the order of their bifurcated surnames to match the campus fashions of the moment.

Take that, Yale.  Smoke that in your bong, Stanford.  Tap this little keg, Harvard.

In case you haven’t realized it, Bowdoin is not about to let you best it in the great insurance coverage race.  No matter how much it costs to prevail.

Ain’t non-profit status a wonderful thing?

</absurdem>  </parody>

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Oldies but Goodies? Or are they “newies?”

From time to time, your correspondent is embarrassed for not providing a steady supply of up to the minute, provocative, and informative essays.

It’s not that we don’t have copious subject matter to contemplate, it’s just that life has a habit of getting in the way.  And that can be in a very good way, as it did today, on an absolutely spectacular fall day, on which I did many things, including some campaign work.  But no matter.

Part of the reason Other Side came to be is that the local media outlet (that would be The Ostrich) would not provide sufficient capacity for our musings.

As it turns out, we have a sizable archive of thought pieces well beyond what they would publish, and we’re just now going back through them to see whether they are dated, or instead, might have relevance even today.

On first look, we are pleasantly surprised.  We found an item just now that reads as if we had written it yesterday, in the context of current events.

So, today we launch a category labeled Oldies but Goodies.  Frank Sinatra, known as Old Blue Eyes, had a unique genius for interpreting the classic American song book. 

Here and now, Old Poppy will do what he can to interpret the classic American thought book.

We open with this number; please let us know what you think of it, and we’re always open to requests!

A Tale of Two Republics

Technorati Tags: ,,

Once upon a time there was a land far, far away, and for those who lived in the land, it was the best of times, it was the worst of times.

And in this land, there were two republics: Taxhikistan, and Taxcutistan. The citizens of both were working hard to prosper and enjoy their lives. But they went about it in different ways, because the leaders they chose had very different ideas about how to make things better for the people.

In Taxhikistan, there was a small business bringing in about $100,000 a year. At first, the small business was paying $10,000 a year in taxes to his government. As time went on, the taxes were increased, until they were $20,000 a year. The business owner complained year after year about the impact of the taxes, but the leaders were unresponsive. Finally, after much prodding, the leaders came up with a plan to help the business owner.

Friday, November 27, 2009

"Cro$$ Border Care:" Canadian "Wait Insurance"

Other Side's daughter and family live in Oakville, Ontario, a large, mostly bedroom community about 20 miles west of Toronto.

She forwarded the article below on health care from her local paper, convinced it would be of interest in our current circumstances. As her friend up there said, where will all those people go when Obama's behemoth of a health-care bill is passed???

Other Side wonders where WE will go when it is passed.

Read it and weep; and let me know when you find a good medical broker and affordable wait insurance.

Here are the relevant links: article 1 and article 2 and article 3.

Cro$$-Border Care
FIRST IN A THREE-PART SERIES
Melinda Dalton, Joe Fantauzzi and Matthew Strader
Published on Nov 26, 2009

Record numbers of Ontarians are being sent to the U. S. by their government for routine health care that should be available at home.

A Metroland Special Report shows thousands of others are funding their own medical treatments south of the border, at high personal cost.

The numbers have been rising for the last 10 years. Government approvals for out-of- country health care funding are up 450 per cent.

Should Ontarians have to use a passport to get health care?

* * *

Oakville’s Kelly Rosettani is happy with the quick treatment she was able to get in the United States for her six-year-old daughter’s curved spine.

When Rosettani’s daughter, Jenna Mayer, went in August for a regular checkup, the doctor said he wanted her to have an X-ray because it looked as if she might have scoliosis, a curvature of the spine.

A Toronto doctor ordered an MRI, and mentioned that depending on its outcome, Jenna might need a brace.

But the family was not satisfied with an MRI wait time of two to six months.

In October, the family went to the U. S. In less than six weeks, they had consulted at an American children’s hospital, seen a specialist in Virginia, acquired a medical brace for Jenna, and returned home.

The family believes they did the right thing by going to the U. S.

“We want people to know that you do not necessarily have to wait, you can get excellent treatment outside the country,” Rosettani said.

Long waits, unavailable procedures and poor physician access are driving record numbers of Ontarians to seek treatment south of the border and sometimes overseas.

A Metroland Special Report on Cross Border Care shows:

• A 450 per cent increase in OHIP approvals for out-of-country care since the beginning of this decade, a period of explosive growth in new technologies and therapies not covered or available here. The province agreed to fund 2,110 procedures or treatments in 2001, and 11,775 last year.

• Patient demand has created a new breed of health-system navigators, known as medical brokers, who find U. S. options for the growing number of Ontario patients who elect to pay for medical services south of the border themselves.

Medical brokers negotiate discount rates with U. S. centres to get Ontarians faster diagnostics, second opinions and surgery.

Brokers say that for every patient sent south by the Ontario government, there may be up to 10 others who go — and pay — on their own.

• Ontario’s spending on out-of-Canada medical services has tripled in the last five years. Payments in 2010 will balloon to $164.3 million, from $56.3 million in 2005. The province said in last month’s economic forecast it needs to increase health spending by $700 million to cover “higher than anticipated” OHIP costs, including services outside the province.

While out-of-country spending is a small part of the $11 billion OHIP pays for all patient services a year, the increase is significant, Ontario’s health minister says.

“Are we looking at ways to reduce out-of-country? Absolutely yes,” said Deb Matthews, who became health minister last month.

Matthews says her ministry is taking steps to improve services and access across Ontario so fewer patients will need to go to the U. S.

At the same time, though, the ministry continues to negotiate preferred rates for Ontario patient visits to U. S. health centres, the Metroland investigation shows.

• Ontario has become a major contractor — a bulk buyer — of American health services this year.

Since spring, the ministry has entered into funding contracts with U. S. hospitals, imaging clinics and residential treatment centres.

It has these “preferred provider” contracts in place with about 40 American medical providers now — and is accepting solicitations from others. Contracts cover diagnostics, cancer care, bariatrics and adolescent behavioural disorders. The ministry says the agreements ensure “more immediate services for patients whose health is at risk.”

It has declined to release details of any of the agreements.

• The province does not track the number of Ontarians who cross the border for care on their own, never seeking government pre-approval or reimbursement.

But major U. S. medical centres contacted by Metroland — including Detroit’s Henry Ford Health System and the Mayo Clinic — say both government-funded and private-pay patient lists are growing.

The Mayo Clinic, which sees about 600 Ontario patients a year, says top reasons include wait times and diagnostic evaluations “when they’ve exhausted options in Canada,” says Mariana Iglesias of the Minnesota-based clinic.

OHIP’s pre-approved funding program for out-of-country care is supposed to fill gaps in health care for high-risk Ontarians.

But patients who use the system express repeated concerns — about the time it takes to get OHIP approval and to appeal, if refused.

“I really believe they make it as difficult as possible,” says Janet Nancarrow of Ottawa who is preparing for an OHIP appeal hearing for her 34-year-old daughter, Lisa, who is taking part in a clinical drug trial at the Mayo Clinic. Lisa has tumours that are encasing her vital organs and invading her system.

Her doctors and family say the trial is her only option short of end-of-life palliative care. With no outside help, Nancarrow said, she had to research precedent cases, find expert witnesses and keep up with enormous paperwork — all while accompanying her daughter back and forth to Minnesota for treatments.

“They shouldn’t put families through this,” she said.

• Ontario continues to struggle with wait times. This month, almost 140,000 people are on wait lists just for CT scans and MRIs.

• Wait-time insurance policies have emerged as the industry caught on to public angst. While no industry figures exist to indicate the level of consumer take-up of the coverage, plans are available to reimburse costs of private treatment when policyholders are forced to wait more than 45 days.

Ontario says it has made strides to reduce waits for the priority procedures it monitors. But the Ontario Health Quality Council — which the ministry set up to review provincial progress — says more needs to be done.

“Many Ontarians still wait too long for urgent cancer surgery, MRI scans … and specialists,” the council says in its 2009 report.

Ontario NDP Leader Andrea Horwath says the OHIP out-of-country surge has taken on momentum and that government must stop the southbound flow.

“The government needs to reinvest the dollars that they’re shoving out the door to private providers of health care in the States, and invest that in providing services here at home,” she said.

* * *

Wait Time Insurance

What it is: A privately obtained insurance that allows Canadians who have excessively long waits for procedures to obtain services at private U. S. clinics.

What it costs: Monthly premiums for wait-time insurance range from $100 to $200 a month.

How it works: Typically, benefits kick in when a covered person is on a wait list for more than 45 days. Coverage includes costs for diagnostic tests and treatment for hundreds of medical conditions. Coverage is subject to terms and conditions of the particular policy.

Saturday, May 14, 2011

PS on “You’ll have to read it…..”

(Ditto on this one; posted earlier and then disappeared.)

A few days ago we posted on the crocodile tears over the health insurance legislation under consideration in Maine.  If you missed it, you can read it here.  It included this passage:

During the House debate leading up to the roll-call vote, more than a dozen Democrats registered their opposition to the provisions of the bill as well as to its fast-track progress through the legislative process.

As fate would have it, a nice couple I’ve never met, other than on the opinion pages of The Ostrich, had a recent letter on this very subject. I won’t name them, but if I did, their names would remind you of Prairie Home Companion and Lake Wobegone.

The letter reads, in part:

Nothing is more important than adequate insurance and nothing should be considered more carefully than changes to the insurance safety nets we now have in place.


Yet, LD 1333 — An Act To Modify Rating Practices for Individual and Small Group Health Plans and To Encourage Value-based Purchasing of Health Care Services — was introduced as a four-page bill, grew to 29 pages in one work session and is now 45 pages and has had no public hearing in its present form.


Few legislators have even had time to do a careful reading, put forth questions and get reliable answers.

The haste with which this is being pushed makes us very uncomfortable and fearful of  unintended consequences and  collateral damage.

Now we could be wrong, but I’d bet you a dozen Frosty’s Donuts (if I could ever catch them when they’re open) that this couple hailed the 2000 page plus Obama-care bill as a long-needed and brilliant solution to all our health care ills.  And never for a moment worried about ‘unintended consequences and collateral damage.’  Funny how that works, isn’t it?

And in case you’re worried that the Bondo patching hadn’t even had a chance to dry, as Rep. Sharon Treat claimed, here’s an update:

  • After the first vote in the house, a second ‘reading’ and vote was taken, and the bill passed again.
  • Yesterday, the senate debated the bill, proposed amendments, and passed the bill in amended form.
  • Now the bill goes back to the house in its new form to see if that chamber will go along with the changes.

Hopefully, Sharon and her friends will have had a chance to read it by now.  But you never know; she may not read it until it passes.

Or not even then.

Friday, September 4, 2009

Moral Hazards, Berry Kool-Aid, and Obama Care

Our lively culture frequently decides to elevate certain words and terms from relative obscurity to common use, or in some cases, overuse. In recent months, the word “narrative” and the term “moral hazard” rank at the top of a list of such preferred expressions.

In the case of “moral hazard,” the individual words are easy enough to comprehend. But based on how the term was most frequently employed, I sensed that a more specific understanding applied.

My instincts were good. A visit to Wikipedia yielded this result:

Moral hazard is the prospect that a party insulated from risk may behave differently from the way it would behave if it were fully exposed to the risk.

Moral hazard is a special case of information asymmetry, a situation in which one party in a transaction has more information than another. The party that is insulated from risk generally has more information about its actions and intentions than the party paying for the negative consequences of the risk.

More broadly, moral hazard occurs when the party with more information about its actions or intentions has a tendency or incentive to behave inappropriately from the perspective of the party with less information.

Moral hazard also arises in a principal-agent problem, where one party, called an agent, acts on behalf of another party, called the principal. The agent usually has more information about his or her actions or intentions than the principal does, because the principal usually cannot completely monitor the agent. The agent may have an incentive to act inappropriately (from the viewpoint of the principal) if the interests of the agent and the principal are not aligned.

Fascinating stuff. Although the term appears to have originated in the insurance world, the concepts described above have superb relevance to our political circumstances. In particular, “information asymmetry” and the “principal-agent problem.”

Let’s examine how these concepts might illuminate the offerings and protestations of Rep. Seth Berry relating to “tax reform” and the ensuing citizen initiative. Berry is certainly a beneficiary of information asymmetry; he clearly knows more about the consequences of the proposed legislation than we do.

Berry is “the party that is insulated from risk” and “generally has more information about its actions and intentions” and we are “the party paying for the negative consequences of the risk.” Berry is our “agent,” and we are the “principals” in this debate.

And in Side’s view, Berry, the agent, has ‘an incentive to act inappropriately,’ because the ‘interests of the agent and the principal are not aligned.’ In so many words, Berry’s interest is maximizing state revenue, while taxpayer interest is preserving income free from state confiscation.

In this sense, Berry and his proposals are a “moral hazard.”

Now let’s turn to the huge national debate over “health care reform,” or as it’s become known in response to public reaction, “health insurance reform.”

Generally speaking, when you purchase insurance in the private market, you receive a copy of the policy along with appropriate endorsements. Yeah, I know, they’re page after page of fine print and complicated language, but at least you have them in front of you. You can study them, and if you wish, hire someone else to translate them for you.

Fast forward to the current national policy discussion. What do you think would happen if you asked one of the advocates of the proposed legislation to provide you with a copy of the insurance policy that you would be signing up for?

Surely I jest, you’re probably thinking. Most of the promoters have no clue what the legislation says; they couldn’t understand it if they tried; and they’re not worried about having to sign up for the results. They’ve got theirs, and they’re not going to do anything that puts it at risk. Meanwhile, they’re telling you that a pig in a poke is what’s best for you.

Even Richard Chapin, who I recently mentioned in less than glowing terms, is on to the scam. He writes this in a recent Times Record letter:

“In other words, we are being asked to approve a giant public program with no idea what it is going to cost and no idea where the money to pay for it is going to come from.”

I hereby revise my opinion of Chapin, who, by the way, is a Harvard graduate, on the basis of this statement alone. Maybe they do have coffee out there where he lives.

That aside, I conclude that “moral hazard” as a concept has its highest relevance in the relationship between citizens and their elected “public servants.” There is probably no more perfect example of information asymmetry, nor of misalignment between the interests of we principals and our agents.

So stay alert as you traverse the waters of public policy. It’s the last place you’ll find hazard markers and other aids to navigation.

Moral or otherwise.

Sunday, May 8, 2011

You’ll have to read it to find out what’s in it…

How soon they forget…

Don’t know whether you’ve been following the news regarding ‘health care reform’ here in Maine.  A bill has been working its way through the legislative process that would restructure some of the relevant regulations in our state, regulations that have arguably given us amongst the highest, if not THE highest insurance premiums in the country.

Here’s a recent report on the progress of that legislation:

During the House debate leading up to the roll-call vote, more than a dozen Democrats registered their opposition to the provisions of the bill as well as to its fast-track progress through the legislative process.

Rep. Sharon Treat, D-Hallowell, a member of the Insurance and Financial Services Committee, compared the bill to a used car “rushed off the lot so fast that the Bondo patching wasn’t even dry.”


The complex bill was “rushed out of committee” after an April 29 work session and approved along party lines without an opportunity for lawmakers to read it or have their questions answered, Treat said in her comments before the vote. The final language of the bill was posted online at about 10 p.m. Wednesday, she said, leaving lawmakers little opportunity to review it before voting on Thursday.


Treat urged legislative newcomers to resist the bill’s “hard sell” by GOP leadership and take the time to understand its impact on long-standing consumer protections and on the insurance industry.

As it turns out, this was just the first of many votes on the legislation.  None the less, we can’t help but reminisce about the current circumstances vis-a-vis Obama-care legislation.

We read that the bill currently working it’s way through Maine’s law making process is 26 pages.  That compares to what we recall was a 2600 page document at the federal level, or 100 times longer on paper than the Maine proposal.

We also recall the incredibly arrogant statement by then Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi that ‘we’ll have to pass the bill to find out what’s in it.’

If only we had a good memory of the ‘Dirigo Health Care’ process, we could probably come up with even better examples.

We don’t need to however, to make it clear just how whiny and duplicitous the new minority is, now that their 35 year plus strangle-hold on Maine governance is no more.

Technorati Tags: ,

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Truth, justice, and the Brunswick way

(Please accept our apologies, Superperson.)

            

“The Best Lobster Roll in Maine.”

“Save up to 70%!”

“Prices may never be lower!”

“Among the best schools in the state.”

“Rates may never be this low again.”

You’re probably familiar with these classics; but have you ever paused to examine their premises with a little critical thought?

One of our favorite examples of the genre is the auto insurance business, currently saturating us with TV ads like this: “People who switched to Depressive saved an average of $543 a year.”  An hour later, along comes another ad: “People who switched to 18th Century saved an average of $521 a year.”

We’re pretty lucky here at Other Side; our annual auto insurance bill is under $1,000.  So we’re thinking that if we just switch our carrier twice, our bill will be down to $0 a year!

That is how it works, isn’t it?  Or are we missing something?

Oh, we’re missing something, pilgrim.  The unanswered question is just how much those who didn’t switch saved by staying with their current insurance company!  But you probably don’t think about that when you’re being dazzled by the on-screen theatrics.

This approach to ‘advertising’ has inspired us to pose a few questions to our readers, especially as you watch school budget theatrics here in Perfect.

First, though, let’s test your thinking with these questions:

- Do you have your car serviced at the shop that charges the most for their services?

- Do you grocery shop at the store that charges more than the others?

- Do you believe you manage your finances better than your neighbors and friends if you spend more for groceries and utilities than they do?  Do you brag to them about spending more, or do they brag to you that they spend more?

Now that we’ve got you thinking, try these:

- How can you find out if Brunswick has excellent schools?

- Ask the salesperson who is showing you homes for sale in town.

- Ask the owner of the house you’re thinking of buying.

- Ask a school board member or school administration staff.

- A well known Real Estate agent asserts that people who move to Brunswick moved here “because of our excellent schools.”

- What reason do the people who decided not to move here give?

- What do the people who move out of town, freeing up a place for others to buy, give as their reason?

- If you asked a Real Estate salesperson in Freeport, or Bath, or Topsham whether people move to their towns “because of the excellent schools,” what would they say?

- If you asked any of these sales-people how they know the schools in their town are excellent, how would they answer?

- Would they say because school officials tell them so?

- Would they say that parents who live in town tell them so?

- How many parents do you think would admit they send their kids to less than wonderful schools if you asked?

- How does one know that our schools are excellent?

- Is it because our teachers are so good, even though we scrupulously avoid rating them or monitoring their performance, because we’ve been told any method for doing so is flawed and unfair?  And the teachers unions have copious data to prove it?

- Is it because of teacher influence on student improvement, even though we refuse to measure such things for the same reasons?

- Is it because of student scores on standardized tests, even though we’ve been warned over and over that such tests are unreliable and can’t be trusted, and that they force teachers to ‘teach to the test,’ rather than focus on learning?

- Why is it that when student scores improve on these tests, even if only marginally, it’s cause for great jubilation, but if scores decline or stay flat, they shouldn’t be used to judge the quality of our schools?

- Is there objective evidence for deciding which towns have the best schools and the best teachers?  That is, other than citing spending and the rate at which its increases as objective evidence?

- If your schools are excellent, what rate of increase in spending is required to keep them excellent, and what rate of increase would render them less than excellent?

In case you’d like to see what kind of data does exist for ranking schools in the state, we direct you here:

2011-12 AYP Results and Explanatory Material

Be sure to read the entire page so you understand what “CIPS” and “monitor” and “making AYP” mean.  Once you have that in your grasp, you can go here for ratings for schools in the state:

2011-12 AYP Status by School

When you do, you’ll see data for the current school year and the prior school year.  You may have to find a way to enlarge the view; try right clicking, or whatever works on the application that opens the table for you.

One more thing: remember, we’re being told our schools are excellent in the present tense, just as we were last year, and that unless we provide whatever they demand in the way of increased funding and higher property taxes, they will no longer be excellent.

We’ll leave it to you to detect the crossover points.  And then you can make your public declaration of how much more you are willing to pay next year, and then how much more the year after that, etc. 

Just like those at Brunswick Community United have declined to do with their signs and their petition.  Apparently, they can’t ‘imagine’ how much more they are willing to ‘invest.’

End Note:  For those of you who missed the message in our opening, let us explain:

“The Best Lobster Roll in Maine.”

- Says who, and by what measure?

“Save up to 70%!”

- ‘up to 70%’ includes everything from 0% on up.

“Prices may never be lower!”

- or they may be lower later; who knows?

“Among the best schools in the state.”

- could you define ‘among,’ please?  And who says what ‘best’ is?

“Rates may never be this low again.”

- but given the cyclic nature of things, they very likely will be in the future.  Or, please come in and get this higher rate while we’re plugging it.

Tuesday, May 30, 2017

Some historical context….

This is an exciting few weeks.  All the turmoil and sturm und drang of the municipal and school budgets, and a referendum asking us to spend $40 million or so on a new school to replace one that was allowed to fall into disrepair, and build it on the site of one that was allowed to ‘structurally fail.’

Most of the same old themes and the same protagonists are apparent in recent events.  The latter includes Rich “its never enough” Ellis, former School Board member, and master number massager.

We realize your study time is limited, but nonetheless, we think you might find some useful information and history in some of our posts in years past.

So we’re passing along links to that information in case you’d like to study up.

The first link is this:

http://othersideofbrunswick.blogspot.com/search?q=insurance

The bulk of the history covered here has to do with the School Department’s purchase of its health insurance coverage for staff from the Maine State Teachers Union, and how that transaction provides hundreds of thousands in funds for them to pay for lobbying in Augusta.

The second link is this:

http://othersideofbrunswick.blogspot.com/search?q=rich+ellis&updated-max=2012-03-06T14:30:00-05:00&max-results=20&start=9&by-date=false

It has to do with our prior exchanges and experiences with Mr. Ellis during his years on the School Board.

Some of the text may appear in difficult to read format because we modified the basic blog format a few years ago, and when the background colors changed, the text colors did not.  If you have this problem, simply ‘select’ the problem text via normal keyboard or cursor actions, and the text will become instantly readable when you do….it will be shown on a white background.

Stay tuned for new materials to appear shortly.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Postscript 2 to LT Ben!, LT Ben!

Two days ago, we mentioned that The Forecaster had published our submittal on the Brunswick school budget on their web site.  We’re expecting it to appear in the print edition tomorrow.

Yesterday, Rich Ellis, a member of the Brunswick School Board, posted a comment on the web site in response. You may have to register and log in to see the comment, which should appear here.

In case you’re unable to access the comment, we offer excerpts from it just as follows (lengthy discussions of the state EPS issue are omitted):

Dear Mr. Schaeffer:

As you seemed confused as to why people refer to a 55% state share as a mandate, choosing instead to describe it as a promise, let me introduce you to Maine Statute 20-A MRSA §15671, sub-§7-B, Essential Services and programs. It is not just a promise or a target, it is codified into Maine law.

This legislation was put into place after Maine voters passed ballot initiative 1 in 2004, which stated that, "the State shall pay at least 55% of the total costs of public education for kindergarten through grade 12, and 100% of the costs of special education services that are mandated by federal or state law."

You say in your letter that nothing in Brunswick was unpredictable, but I would have to say as someone who has made a living predicting numbers and building multi-year forecasts, you underestimate the complexity of this process and its influencing factors.

Now, in regards to the rest of your letter, there are several errors within your figures and/or assertions. I know the data is challenging to arrive at, and I am not going to go into a detailed response on each error, but basically:

• Brunswick has never spent the $13,559 you suggest per pupil. In FY11, the most recently reported year, we spent $29.6 million against a budget of 2,734 subsidizable resident pupils or $10,842 per pupil. If you base it on actual resident pupils that year, 2470.5, you get $11,998 per pupil, but that's not how budgets are planned.

• Brunswick's actual spending only exceeded State 100% EPS, a measure of adequacy which does not cover all programs, by about $474 per pupil in FY11. The gap has hovered in that range for each of the last six years. If you think the State's EPS calculation calculates a luxury school system, you just might be alone. The fact that we are so close to that figure would indicate that we are far too close to funding a purely "adequate" education in Brunswick.

• You are mixing residential pupil expenses in FY06 (apples) with total budget approved per pupil in FY12 (oranges)

• While you correctly identify enrollment as a driving factor, state property valuation is equally as important because it determines how much a town must pay before the State kicks in a penny. Between FY06 and FY12, Brunswick's town Valuation has increased 49.6% or 5.9% per year. Living in Brunswick, was it your perception that our property value had increased that much during this recession? I know it certainly didn't match my expectations. Anyhow, the result? The state expects the town share per pupil to increase by 70.5%, from $3,744 to $6,532 per pupil. Trying planning for that rate of increase.

Anyhow, while I am pretty sure our philosophies on local education are diametrically opposed, I would encourage you to get better informed and to contribute more productively by helping to find actual solutions instead of just complaining or taking the annual shot across the bow. Hope to see you at the upcoming budget meetings.

Best regards,
Rich Ellis

As we reread his comments again, we realize that perhaps Mr. Ellis is trying to pull the wool over our eyes with the term ‘subsidizable resident pupils.’  This will get wonky really quick, but the difference could be between the three year rolling average enrolment, and actual enrolment in the current year.

Frankly, if that’s what he is doing, it is propaganda and deception of the worst sort.  But we’ll let him answer.  And we should go easy on him; most likely, the masters of numeric manipulation in the School Department have fed him this Kool-Aid.

As you well know, your faithful reporter is not one to shrink from a challenge.  And so we copy here our response to Mr. Ellis’ thoughts; it will not appear in The Forecaster print edition, and you may not have access to it on the web.

Here it is:

Mr. Ellis:

Thanks for your extensive response. As you can imagine, I am quite busy keeping the bank of computers I use to generate false numbers and spurious arguments humming along. But I do wish to offer a timely reply to your efforts, and trust you will consider what follows in that regard.

Let me begin with the following. While you and virtually every other school board member I can think of, not to mention superintendents, are intent on shifting the problem elsewhere, it all begins and ends with spending, and the Brunswick School Department has an unblemished record in that regard. Nothing you say or do can change the recorded history of approved budgets and the enrolment reports to the state. Unless you wish to suggest that some or all have been falsified. Should you provide numbers (with sources) that correct those I have been collecting for more than ten years, I will be happy to consider them against the budgets, Department data, and state records I have relied upon.

That said, thank you for your kind explanation of the legislation in this area. Please note as well that the Maine State Constitution says:

Article VIII. -- Part First.
Education.

Section 1. Legislature shall require towns to support public schools; duty of Legislature. A general diffusion of the advantages of education being essential to the preservation of the rights and liberties of the people; to promote this important object, the Legislature are authorized, and it shall be their duty to require, the several towns to make suitable provision, at their own expense, for the support and maintenance of public schools; and it shall further be their duty to encourage and suitably endow, from time to time, as the circumstances of the people may authorize, all academies, colleges and seminaries of learning within the State; provided, that no donation, grant or endowment shall at any time be made by the Legislature to any literary institution now established, or which may hereafter be established, unless, at the time of making such endowment, the Legislature of the State shall have the right to grant any further powers to alter, limit or restrain any of the powers vested in any such literary institution, as shall be judged necessary to promote the best interests thereof.

http://www.maine.gov/legis/const/

So let’s agree up front that the State’s record of complying with clearly written obligations is less than distinguished.

As to the initiative you cite, what it said on the ballot is a starting point, since legislatures are then free to do what they will with the language.

That little detail aside, I would remind you that the initiative you refer to was passed with promises of 15% property tax reduction statewide; I know; I still have one of the signs. Note as well from your own sources that the education unions provided the majority of funding for the campaign. And I can remember Nick Mavadones, then an official at the MMA, and in recent years, mayor of Portland, in the TV ads urging a yes vote and making the promise. You may also recall that this was the establishment’s offering to fend off the so-called Palesky initiative modeled after California’s proposition 13.

I don’t know about you, but we’ve lived in our current house for nearly 15 years, and not once has our tax bill gone down that I can remember. And it is thousands higher than it was at the beginning.

I took a read through the statutory language, and found more than enough passages to confuse someone with a better mind than I. Some of them suggest that the figure the state is obligated to pay is less than 50%, not to mention any number of complexities associated with baselines, definitions, pension payments, etc.

The fact is, the GPA per student, whether it reaches 55% or not, has increased significantly on a per student basis. My figures show that it has increased from $3432 in FY 06 to $4765 in the current school year, an increase of 39%.

The fact is, the GPA enrolment figures are based on a sliding 3 year average, as shown in the appended statutory language. Given Brunswick’s precipitous enrolment decline, you should at least admit the state is cutting you some major slack here.

The fact is, the state pays for sizable sums for teacher retirement and retired teacher benefits, amounts not shown in local budgets in any form. So one could argue that the state is paying considerably more toward ‘education’ than you suggest.

Here is one relevant passage:

Beginning in fiscal year 2011-12, the annual targets for the state share percentage of the total cost of funding public education from kindergarten to grade 12 including the cost of the components of essential programs and services plus the state contributions to teacher retirement, retired teachers' health insurance and retired teachers' life insurance are as follows.

(1) For fiscal year 2011-12, the target is 49.60%.

(2) For fiscal year 2012-13, the target is 52.50%.

(3) For fiscal year 2013-14 and succeeding years, the target is 55%.

The fact is, per student enrolment costs have grown exactly as I indicated.

The fact is, if per student costs had gone up by 5% a year since FY 05, our budget would now be $29.1 million, or $4,200,000 less than it is. I should think that an annual increase of 5% in “tuition” would be considered a generous growth rate by virtually any standard.

“You are mixing residential pupil expenses in FY06 (apples) with total budget approved per pupil in FY12 (oranges).”

Excuse me? I’m afraid you lost me here. Fruit salad aside, my standard practice is to divide the total budget by total enrolment to arrive at what I call ‘per student spending.’ If you have another way of calculating this, I’d like to see it.

The fact is that negotiations for a new teachers contract will begin soon, if they aren’t already underway; please tell me what you are doing to see that these costs are kept within reason, and that benefit costs are being restructured to be more in keeping with widely based employment norms. And what’s being done to see that the worst teachers don’t get paid the same as the best teachers. I don’t know what field you work in, but unless you consider yourself to be at the bottom of the performance scale, I doubt you would be happy with such an arrangement, or consider it ‘fair.’

Along those lines, please tell us what the Department is doing to see that the millions we send the MEA for insurance don’t include several hundred thousand to be used for political activism. And beyond that, what you’re doing to see that the insurance costs benefit from a competitive process.

The fact is that the overwhelming majority of budget increases over the years go to teacher salary increases, warranted or not, and benefits so generous as to make the average Maine taxpayer faint in disbelief. On top of the best job security one could hope for.

The fact is that just a few years ago, we had four schools teaching grades K-5, and we now have one school teaching each. If that hasn’t resulted in major cost savings, I don’t know what would, over and above the enrolment declines. Four school lunch services have been reduced to two; two fewer schools require bus service; classrooms per grade should be significantly lower due both to enrolment decline and efficiencies; support staff and administrative staff should be lower as well. EG, budgets should be lower, yet they have not declined.

I get that you are angry with the state and wish to drive all the attention towards Augusta and away from Brunswick. Perhaps that is why you chose not to address the other realities I mentioned.

As to your comment about ‘predicting numbers’ and the associated difficulty, no one had to ‘predict’ the loss of Durham students and military dependents any more than one has to ‘predict’ the age of their children in coming years. Influencing factors?? My goodness; they were a certainty, givens with entirely known effects on revenue from those sources.

Want to talk about trouble ‘predicting?’ Perhaps you should review the Planning Decisions studies that said Brunswick’s enrolment would rebound just like magic. And the predictions made to justify building the new school.

In particular, I note that you completely ignore the windfall aspects of the loss of military dependents and Durham students. Do you dispute that these students were not bringing ‘fair share’ revenue with them?

And my figures for per year student spending are accurate. For example, in the current year, the approved budget is $33,301,672. If you divide that by 2456, the enrolment reported to the state in October, you get a figure of $13,559.31.

As a member of the school board, I would have expected you to have up to date budget data. If you are unable to get the info you need, please let me know, and I’ll forward the budget files to you.

Readers can find the current year budget here: http://www.brunswick.k12.me.us/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Approved-School-Budget-11-12.pdf

I refer you to page two in the document, though you may wish to become familiar with the rest of it as well.

To repeat, while you are intent on shifting the problem elsewhere, it all comes down to spending, and the Brunswick School Department’s are a matter of public record. Nothing you say or do can change the recorded history of approved budgets and the enrolment reports to the state. Unless you wish to suggest that both were falsified.

Anyhow, while I am pretty sure our philosophies on local education funding are diametrically opposed, I would encourage you to get better informed and to contribute more productively by helping to find actual solutions instead of just shooting the messenger or taking the annual swipe across the messenger’s posterior. Hopefully, at the upcoming budget meetings, you’ll have accurate figures in hand.

I have no doubt however, that your ‘actual solutions’ will consist of spending however much more it takes to preserve the status quo, rather than reforming the enterprise to reflect economic, demographic, structural, and performance realities.

If you have the time, though, we’d love to hear what you and the school board have done and are planning on doing to improve student education in Brunswick, aside from giving the teachers annual guaranteed raises regardless of their performance or student outcomes. Suggesting that paying teachers more will yield better education for our kids next year than this year is an insult to the concept of teacher professionalism, and even worse, an affront to taxpayers.

Best regards,

Pem Schaeffer

PS: please tell us where the extra $5,329 we’re spending per student compared to FY 05 has gone.

PSPS: you can find ample commentary on the same issues from last year here:

http://othersideofbrunswick.blogspot.com/2011_05_01_archive.html

Feel free to offer your criticisms on the points contained therein; I will do my best to respond.

PSPSPS: Since you have a firm grip on Maine Statute, perhaps you can comment on this passage from §15671:

B. The annual targets for the state share percentage of the statewide adjusted total cost of the components of essential programs and services are as follows.

(1) For fiscal year 2005-06, the target is 52.6%.

(2) For fiscal year 2006-07, the target is 53.86%.

(3) For fiscal year 2007-08, the target is 53.51%.

(4) For fiscal year 2008-09, the target is 52.52%.

(5) For fiscal year 2009-10, the target is 48.93%.

(6) For fiscal year 2010-11, the target is 45.84%.

(7) For fiscal year 2011-12 , the target is 46.18%. [2011, c. 380, Pt. C, §2 (AMD).]

C. Beginning in fiscal year 2011-12, the annual targets for the state share percentage of the total cost of funding public education from kindergarten to grade 12 including the cost of the components of essential programs and services plus the state contributions to teacher retirement, retired teachers' health insurance and retired teachers' life insurance are as follows.

(1) For fiscal year 2011-12, the target is 49.60%.

(2) For fiscal year 2012-13, the target is 52.50%.

(3) For fiscal year 2013-14 and succeeding years, the target is 55%.